Episode 12 - D.Gray-man Hallow - Anime News Network

USA & Canada

  • World
  • USA & Canada
  • Australia & New-Zealand
  • Southeast Asia
We need your help. Good journalism costs money, and advertising doesn’t bring in what it used to. For just $1 a month you can help secure Anime News Network’s future.

D.Gray-man Hallow Episode 12

by Anne Lauenroth, Sep 20th 2016

How would you rate episode 12 of
D.Gray-man Hallow ?

He always puts others first. He gets hurt trying to save others from their sorrow!

To Lenalee, the proof of Allen's virtue and loyalty as an Exorcist is just a critical flaw in Tyki's eyes. Allen embraces his destiny as an Exorcist despite the not remotely unambiguous nature of Innocence, and Allen rejects his Noah memory even if it obviously connects Nea to Mana. Allen has no idea who he is, so he compensates by trying to save everyone else, blaming himself for things he has no control over while clinging to the words of a dead man who might be as far from the purehearted clown Allen wants to remember as Tyki is from being his friend. I actually have to remind myself of what Tyki did to Suman Dark and all his other victims in the first series, since his concern feels so genuine and his words are so necessary for Allen to hear. It's time to stop playing the hero to avoid dealing with your own issues.

The shonen hero having powers of both light and darkness isn't exactly a revolutionary concept. So far, however, it doesn't look like being a part of both worlds will help Allen become the designated champion to save the world in the typical vein. Rather, it looks like fate simply managed to screw him twice. Brief flashbacks to better times rub in the tragedy of Allen losing what remains of his surrogate family. Despite the new art style and changed cast, these are still the same people we laughed and suffered with (even if Kanda's younger self looks unconvincing with Hallow's character design). But it's not the visuals that make this well-trodden device work so well. Just like at other crucial moments throughout Hallow – Kanda thanking Allen, Alma's death, and now Allen and Lenalee's goodbye – Kaoru Wada's music plays a key role in triggering emotions I didn't know I still remembered from years ago. These are the few moments when an almost too-faithful adaptation manages to briefly elevate itself beyond its source material.

Hallow also deserves props for giving characters like Miranda and Krory at least a nod, when the manga had mostly forgotten about them at this point. One of D.Gray-man's strongest suits had always been its colorful ensemble, and while the introduction of new players was necessary to finally tell the carefully built-up and long overdue backstory of one of the main characters, it nonetheless meant other favorites would disappear into the background for a while. It's nice to see how well Timothy has grown into the responsibility of being an Exorcist, just as it is sad to see Miranda still limited to her timid, insecure self after all that she's been through and proven herself alongside her comrades. Krory, meanwhile, is allowed to be a real badass, and Lenalee finally gets to kick some Akuma butt again before breaking down in tears once more for the scene I originally assumed to be Hallow's endpoint.

While Allen's decision of going away to avoid putting the people who want to fight alongside him in danger is probably necessary for him to figure out who he is, it also means the same people he's doing this for will have to fight against him eventually, something Lenalee finds impossible to cope with. Leaving our characters here would have ended Hallow on a rather depressing note, so the idea of at least a glimmer of hope is comforting, even if the preview gives reason for both pleasant anticipation and concern in the face of what's left to come – and how much ground they intend to cover in a mere 23 minutes.

If one thing has been consistent throughout this adaptation, it has been inconsistent pacing. We're obviously not going to have enough time to solve all the remaining plot threads, so opening up a new box of the Thirds' mystery in the penultimate episode feels frustrating rather than suspenseful. With the content of at least 3 manga chapters featured in the preview (hence my concern about the possibility of emotional payoff), I'm still an advocate of Allen's mantra:

Don't stop... Keep walking.

And maybe ask the subtitles to agree on a consistent plural for the Noah(s) in the next season.

Rating: B-

D.Gray-man Hallow is currently streaming on Funimation.


discuss this in the forum (75 posts) | bookmark/share with:

back to D.Gray-man Hallow
Episode Review homepage / archives

RightStuf - Anime, Manga and More ⬈ ⬋ - + column 1 comments

Manga Answerman - Why Are American Manga Publishers So Coy About Licenses?

Jul 20, 13:00 1 comments manga If you ask an American manga publisher about whether or not they're going to license a title you love, they'll be super coy and weird about it even if they have every intention of releasing it. Why is that? Deb digs in. ― Just got back from Anime Expo, and I'm at San Diego Comic-Con as you read this, where I'll be doing more of the same: going to the manga publishers' panels and reporting on what I ... review 9 comments

Hinamatsuri—Episodes 1-12 streaming

Jul 20, 10:00 9 comments anime Once you get past its oddball premise, Hinamatsuri offers plenty of laughs and charm throughout its unusual run. Nick Creamer has the details. ― You wouldn't think a show about a family composed of a yakuza mobster and a psychic alien girl could be described as “warm and relatable,” but Hinamatsuri is weird in more ways than that. Idly combining trenchant commentary on homelessness, running child lab... column 18 comments

This Week in Anime - What the Hell is Happening in Fate/Extra Last Encore?

Jul 19, 17:46 18 comments anime F/E LE premiered on Netflix last month to plenty of head-scratching from even experienced Fate fanatics. We run down this show's often baffling plot and what went wrong in adaptation. ― Fate/Extra Last Encore premiered on Netflix last month to plenty of head-scratching from even experienced Fate fanatics. This week, Nick and Jacob run down this show's often baffling plot and what went wrong in adapta... column 9 comments

This Week in Games - In Memoriam: Hiroshi Kajiyama

Jul 19, 12:00 9 comments games Heidi memorializes the distinct and uniquely evocative designs of Hiroshi Kajiyama, illustrator for Shining Force, Dragon Quest and more. PLUS: Dragon Ball FighterZ, Sonic Mania Plus, Granblue Fantasy and much more! ― I hate to start this week's column out on a downer note, but I feel like I need to make the most of an opportunity to eulogize a creator I really admired who suddenly passed on this wee... interview 3 comments

Interview: Persona 5 The Animation at Anime Expo 2018

Jul 18, 14:00 3 comments events The director and producer of Persona 5 The Animation stormed Anime Expo 2018 this year - we've got an interview with the guys behind the anime, and a full panel report from the show. ― At this year's Anime Expo, Persona 5 the Animation's director Masashi Ishihama and producer Kazuki Adachi were kind enough to agree to a one-on-one interview with Anime News Network regarding their newest project. One ... column 15 comments

Answerman - Why Did US Anime Publishers Experiment With Western Cartoons?

Jul 18, 13:00 15 comments anime Once upon a time, Funimation and ADV Films licensed western cartoons for release into the fabled "mass market". Justin gets into this bit of history. ― Taylor asked: I've gone through Funimation's catalog on DVDEmpire and watched the "not-so-hidden secret" videos from Skippy on Youtube, and from what I saw, during the mid-00s, Funimation licensed several cartoons for release on DVD and VHS (includin... review 23 comments

Pokémon the Movie: Everyone's Story

Jul 18, 10:00 23 comments anime This ensemble film tells a myriad of charming stories with some of the most impressive animation in the franchise's history. Callum May gives his take on this next step in Pokémon's ongoing evolution. ― Pokemon movies are often known for cheesy titles like “Zoroark: Master of Illusions” and “Hoopa and the Clash of Ages”, but the title of Pokemon the Movie: Everyone's Story has a very distinct meaning... column 21 comments

This Week in Anime - Did FLCL Progressive Live Up to its Predecessor?

Jul 17, 12:00 21 comments anime FLCL Progressive came to an end last weekend, and fans are still divided on the results. This week, Nick and Steve parse their gut feelings on this highly anticipated sequel. ― FLCL Progressive came to an end last weekend, and fans are still divided on the results. This week, Nick and Steve parse their gut feelings on this highly anticipated sequel. Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by the... review 4 comments

K: Seven Stories R:B -Blaze-

Jul 17, 10:00 4 comments anime The K franchise's transition to the big screen for the first of six films is unfortunately not off to a promising start. Lynzee Loveridge has the details. ― As a franchise, K had slipped under my radar; I knew it as little more than the colorful anime by the creators of Hand Shakers. So I quickly got myself acquainted with a story that included two television anime and a movie that bridges the gap be... site news 45 comments

Your Daily Streaming Reviews Schedule: Summer 2018

Jul 16, 16:47 45 comments anime The results are in and we have your Daily Streaming Reviews schedule for Summer 2018! ― This season's poll results have been tallied and we've put together the schedule for the Spring 2018 Daily Streaming Reviews! We may add coverage of more spring anime based on future reader interest, so let us know what you'd like to see as the season progresses! (Please note that Back Street Girls and Baki the Gr... All material Copyright © 1998-2018 Anime News Network. All rights reserved.
served by kurisu-chan
cloudflare ray# 43d78b3362a2920c-EWR