This website does readability filtering of other pages. All styles, scripts, forms and ads are stripped. If you want your website excluded or have other feedback, use this form.

Opinion: A non-decision from the IOC | Sports | DW.COM | 24.07.2016

success fail Jun JUL Aug 25 2015 2016 2017 12 captures 24 Jul 2016 - 26 Aug 2018 About this capture COLLECTED BY Organization: Internet Archive These crawls are part of an effort to archive pages as they are created and archive the pages that they refer to. That way, as the pages that are referenced are changed or taken from the web, a link to the version that was live when the page was written will be preserved.

Then the Internet Archive hopes that references to these archived pages will be put in place of a link that would be otherwise be broken, or a companion link to allow people to see what was originally intended by a page's authors.

The goal is to fix all broken links on the web. Crawls of supported "No More 404" sites. Collection: GDELT A daily crawl of more than 200,000 home pages of news sites, including the pages linked from those home pages. Site list provided by The GDELT Project TIMESTAMPS

  1. Inhalt
  2. Navigation
  3. Weitere Inhalte
  4. Metanavigation
  5. Suche
  6. Choose from 30 Languages
Wrong language? Change it here DW.COM has chosen English as your language setting. DW AKADEMIE ABOUT DW Deutsche Welle TOP STORIES / Sports


Opinion: A non-decision from the IOC

Russian athletes can take part in Rio - provided they prove they're clean to international authorities. With this, says DW's Olivia Gerstenberger, the IOC is forlornly trying to pass the buck and also save face.

It was the first real acid test while in office for the German president of the International Olympic Committee, Thomas Bach. And he flunked it. Instead of reaching a clear decision on how to deal with the Russian Olympic Committee, he's leaving this for individual international sports federations to decide. They should now decide whether a given Russian athlete was part of the state-sponsored doping program or not. That's more than a move designed to leave a back-door entry to Rio - Bach might as well be paving the road there.

Thinking about individual, innocent sportsmen and women, you could take refuge in the Latin of the courtroom: In dubio pro reo - where in doubt, for the accused. That's precisely the line which Bach took.

"The fundamental question was: to what extent can an individual athlete be held responsible for a system in a country?" Bach asked, speaking of the "presumption of innocence," and stressing the "strict criteria, which every Russian athlete must meet." He came close to lauding the IOC decision, "because clean athletes will not be punished for a system they were not party to." Now, he said, they're at liberty to prove just this to international doping testers.

Cover-ups are costly in the end

But how intensive, how unified can these investigations now be? Even these new criteria aren't entirely clear: for instance, it's said that numerous negative tests must be provided at an international level - only it's not clear how many that is. More to the point, perhaps, there's only two weeks now until the Games start in Rio. Which specialist sports federation will willingly exclude its own stars now? Tennis, for instance, has already made it clear that all seven nominated Russians will be going to Rio.

DW's Olivia Gerstenberger believes the decision's not really fair on anyone

It's impossible to really call Sunday's decision a just one. For, if you follow Bach's own argumentation, then there could well be Russian track and field athletes who are clean - but they still face the IAAF'S blanket ban. That also affects any Russian sports stars who have doped in the past, like for instance the star witness Yuliya Stepanova. As a confessed former doper, she helped to unveil the extent of the Russian scandal. But, by the IOC's standards, she now doesn't meet the IOC's "ethical" criteria. Former dopers from other countries who have served their suspensions, meanwhile, can compete. Stepanova was at least invited to come and watch the Games - from the stands. What a message that sends to potential whistleblowers of the future.

A convenient non-decision

A "zero-tolerance strategy," which Bach forever expounds, is something really rather different. You can't help but wonder what would have been necessary for the IOC - ultimately the organizers of the entire Olympics - to actually act. It allows Russia, a country that has demonstrably doped with state support for years now, to take to the field in Rio - under the Russian flag, too. This will put the Olympic ideal to a very tough test, or it could simply render it risible.

In any case, this is a slap in any clean athlete's face. For which of them would not feel a bitter aftertaste, if sharing a Rio podium with a Russian competitor? The IOC, and by extension Thomas Bach, should have followed the clear recommendation of the World Anti-Doping Agency. They really should have shown some backbone and made a clear statement in the worldwide fight against doping. With this decision, the credibility of the organization is shattered once more, while that of state-sponsored doping actually receives a minor boost.

Have something to say? Leave your comments in the section below. The thread closes automatically 24 hours after publication.

DW recommends

IOC decides against blanket Olympic ban for Russia

Russian athletes have not been completely banned from the Olympic Games in Rio de Janeiro by the International Olympic Committee (IOC). The final decision will rest with the international sporting federations. (24.07.2016)

Court of Arbitration for Sport rejects Russian appeal against IAAF doping ban

World sports' top appeals court throws out a Russian bid to overturn its track and field ban. Still, the final call on which Russians - if any - go to Rio rests with the International Olympic Committee. (21.07.2016)

IOC 'will explore the legal options' of a blanket Russian doping ban at Rio Olympics

The International Olympic Committee is seeking legal advice weighing a possible Russian ban "versus the right to individual justice" for clean competitors. A commission will probe allegations of wrongdoing. (19.07.2016)

State-run Russian doping at Sochi identified, WADA calls for outright Rio ban

Canadian lawyer Richard McLaren says his independent team uncovered a systematic pattern of doping "beyond a reasonable doubt." The World Anti-Doping Agency tells the IOC to consider a blanket Rio Games ban for Russia. (18.07.2016)

Timeline: Doping in Russia

For almost two years, revelations and allegations of Russian doping have been grabbing the headlines. The high-point, so far, being WADA's report and call for a complete Olympic ban. Here's an overview of the key events. (19.07.2016)

Related content

IOC: No blanket ban on Russian athletes 24.07.2016

The International Olympic Committee has raised the ire of anti-doping crusaders after it decided not to impose a blanket ban on Russian athletes for the Rio Olympic Games. The 28 Federations will decide the fate of individual Russian athletes.

Opinion: Putting it on a plate for the IOC 21.07.2016

Following the CAS verdict on Russia's track and field ban for Rio, the IOC must follow up by excluding Russia completely, says DW's Stefan Nestler. Yet such a step should only be the beginning.

IOC decides against blanket Olympic ban for Russia 24.07.2016

Russian athletes have not been completely banned from the Olympic Games in Rio de Janeiro by the International Olympic Committee. The final decision will rest with the international sporting federations.

Results and Table

Keep up to date with the latest scores and the points table in the Bundesliga.

© 2016 Deutsche Welle | Privacy Policy | Legal notice | Contact | Mobile version