This website does readability filtering of other pages. All styles, scripts, forms and ads are stripped. If you want your website excluded or have other feedback, use this form.

Puerto Rico - Wellsphere

success fail Mar APR May 01 2009 2010 2011 45 captures 01 Apr 2010 - 08 Mar 2016 About this capture COLLECTED BY Organization: Alexa Crawls Starting in 1996, Alexa Internet has been donating their crawl data to the Internet Archive. Flowing in every day, these data are added to the Wayback Machine after an embargo period. Collection: alexa_web_2010 this data is currently not publicly accessible. TIMESTAMPS Home Communities Classes & Events Resources Near You WellTools My Wellsphere Sign Up! Log in

Overview Blog Posts Discussions People More Latest Activity News Pictures Twitter Updates Videos Join this community! + Bookmark page › Share page: All HealthBloggers By Dr. Mark Frisse Specialty: Internal Medicine Blog: [web.archive.org] › View Profile › Send a message › Write on Whiteboard

More from this Member

AHIC Pay-For-Performance For-Profit Health Information Exchanges The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) Announces Four New Programs Visualizing the Stimulus Bill - the Hive Group » View All

Puerto Rico

Posted Sep 07 2008 8:39pm Because of the close contest between two Democratic presidential candidates, something unusual is happening. For a few brief days, the eyes of the Nation will be turned on the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. To some, Puerto Rico is an ancestral home; to others, it is a tourist destination; to those who help forge policy, it is a potential laboratory for health care reform.

Among the diverse states and territories constituting the United States, Puerto Rico is unique. Puerto Rico was ceded from Spain to the United States through the Treaty of Paris in 1898; it has governed through a formal civilian structure since the passage of the Foraker Act in 1900. Since the passage in 1917of the Jones-Shafroth Act the United States Congress has characterized the Commonwealth as an “organized but unincorporated” territory of the United States. Under this Act, residents were granted U.S. citizenship by statute and since that time have served in the United States military service. This Act affirmed a primary responsibility of the United States in maintaining control over economic, defense, and other basic governmental affairs and reiterates the United States Congress’s authority to overrule actions taken by the Commonwealth Legislature.

In 1947, the U.S. Congress approved a law allowing the election of the governor by the people of Puerto Rico. On July 3, 1950, the U.S. Congress passed the Puerto Rican Federal Relations Act. This law gave Puerto Rico the right to establish a government and a constitution for the internal administration of the Puerto Rico government and “on matters of purely local concern.

In 1993 most of the government’s health care facilities and services were sold and their management turned over to non-government entities generally under managed care arrangements. This far more decentralized system radically changed the Department of Public Health’s influence and authority in provisioning care services.

Although the impact on efficiency and quality is controversial there is some consensus on the unintended consequences of these moves. As is the case in the 50 states, the health care delivery could benefit from less fragmentation; it would provide more good if organizations providing preventive services, health promotion, and health maintenance were better coordinated; its diverse regions and communities require a better fit of health care services; it needs a stronger infrastructure for monitoring quality, financing health care services, improving outcomes, and providing consumers with greater empowerment and choices. It is, in a nutshell, facing the same challenges as those of the 50 states and other territories - but one can argue that its situation is even more acute.

Puerto Rico’s ability to combine local and federal financing for health care programs is hobbled by its unique relationship with the Federal government. In contrast to “incorporated territories” that may petition for statehood, the “unincorporated territory” of Puerto Rico is not subject to the Constitution’s Tax Uniformity Clause on all Federal duties, imposts, and excise. Although Puerto Ricans do pay import/export taxes, commodity taxes, and payroll taxes (Medicare, Social Security) most are not required to pay Federal income tax.

Although Puerto Ricans do not pay federal income tax, few would have a significant tax burden: the median household income in Puerto Rico is only 34% of the U.S median household income (2000 census) and less than half of that of citizens in the State of Mississippi.

While many health indicators in Puerto Rico are more ominous even than those published for Mississippi, in 2006 the latter state received 78.6% in federal support for every Medicaid dollar spent (the FMAP or federal matching assistance percentage), while Federal spending caps first initiated in 1968 have limited Puerto Rico’s matching percentage to an effective rate of 18%.

The 50 states can receive up to 90% reimbursement through Medicaid for critical health information technologies; Puerto Rico is not eligible for these supplements. According to 2005 Congressional testimony by Governor Anibal Acevedo-Vila, had FMAP been allowed to operate without the cap instead of the 18% effective rate of the previous year, the Commonwealth would have received $1.7 billion dollars in federal Medicaid support instead of the $219 million received. Translated to monthly amounts, federal Medicaid support in the states approximated $330 per month per participant; the amount in Puerto Rico was about $20 per month.

Funding and health care status are only a part of the obstacles Puerto Rico faces. Its health care delivery system, health care resources, and health care financing mechanisms have been said to have been in a state of decline since the introduction of managed care programs in the early 1990s. The hospital beds per capita in the Commonwealth are less than 2/3 the average across the 50 states; salaries for health care professionals of all types are lower and emigration to the 50 states is common. As vital care resources emigrate from the Commonwealth, some believe that a growing number of Puerto Rican residents needing chronic or long-term care will emigrate as well, shifting the financial burden for care to these same states.

It is within this context of controversy, internal dispute, and at times acrimonious dialogue with the Congress and Federal Executive Branch that Puerto Rico must navigate a course to health care reform. The creation, financing, and administration of such reforms very much depends on the perception – in Washington, among the Congress, and within the Commonwealth – on the rights and responsibilities of all parties within this historically unique and volatile relationship.

Puerto Rico's voice - and their subsequent actions - may say a lot about how other parts of the Nation can address similar urgent health care financing and delivery concerns.

Readings:
« Prev The May, 2008 CBO Report: Evidence on the Costs and Benefits of Health Information Technology (Publication number 2976). Next » Incentives for e-Prescribing Report this Share article Bookmark article

Related Articles

'The Dr. Oz Show' and the National Association of Free Clinics Host One Day of Free Public HealthCare I’m Stuck with United HealthCare – Would Welcome a Change to Try a Public Health Insurance Option More and more public health educ ... Experts versus the public on health care: Reconciling the gaps The New England Journal of Medicine & Handguns: Fair Assessment of the Threat to Public Health? MiniClinics on the March: Politics, Policy, and the Public's Health Elk meat recalled due to CWD Boulder County Health Department and Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment "Novel" public health ethics More on Reaching Young Males with Public Health Education Messages A Message From Dr. Andrew Wakefield - The Truth About Public Health's Promotion of Vaccination Post a comment Post comment Write a comment:

Wellsphere Info

About Contact Us FAQs Feedback Privacy Policy Terms of Use Blog ©2010 Wellsphere. All Rights Reserved. WellPages: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 See all the latest blog posts. Acai Berry Juice Scam Weight Watchers Points List Wellsphere List of High Protein Foods List of Low Carb Foods 5k Equals How Many Miles Causes of Swollen Ankles Stage 4 Cancer Survival Rate Itchy Red Spots Arm Numbness and Tingling Symptoms of Vitamin D Deficiency Pictures of Skin Rashes Mucus Discharge Pregnancy Swollen Red Rash Small Red Itchy Bumps Itchy Bumps on Legs Red Spots on Tongue Swollen Lymph Nodes Burning After Urination Bloating After Eating Rash Around Mouth Thigh Slimming Exercises Watery Discharge Pregnancy List of High Calorie Foods Tingling Toes and Fingers Red Purple Spots on Legs List of Fruits and Vegetables Pelvic Exam Heat Rash Pictures 6 Week Fetus Non Itchy Rash Red Spots in Mouth Leg Ache Prednisone and Alcohol Bumps in Throat Arm Muscle Spasm Blocked Sweat Glands How to Lose 10 Pounds Phlegm Throat Tingling in Legs Causes of Swollen Lip Remedies for Swollen Glands Remedies for Swollen Ankles Inflamed Cervix Numbness in Toes Causes of Pain Pain in Upper Thigh Low Red Blood Cell Count Causes of Swollen Glands Causes of Swollen Lymph Nodes 6 Weeks Pregnant Symptoms 29 Weeks Pregnant Metallic Taste in the Mouth Swollen Parotid Gland Skeletal System Diseases Wellsphere does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See additional information.