success fail Feb MAR Apr 06 2007 2008 2009 77 captures 06 Mar 2008 - 13 May 2018 About this capture COLLECTED BY Organization: Alexa Crawls Starting in 1996, Alexa Internet has been donating their crawl data to the Internet Archive. Flowing in every day, these data are added to the Wayback Machine after an embargo period. Collection: 52_crawl this data is currently not publicly accessible. TIMESTAMPS
By Nate Anderson | Published: March 05, 2008 - 11:04AM CT
Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails made headlines again this week as he released his new, four-part instrumental album Ghosts I-IV, at a variety of price points, including a $300 super-deluxe package. He's also giving away Ghosts I at no charge, even throwing the tracks up on The Pirate Bay for anyone to download. And it appears to be working quite well for Reznor, who has managed to sell all 2,500 copies of his $300 package without major label backing or much in the way of splashy marketing. If Reznor's earlier experiments in digital distribution failed to recoup their costs, he's clearly learned his lesson: grossing $750,000 in the space of three days isn't a bad haul for any businessperson.
Reznor was disappointed by an earlier experiment in which he released the music of his friend Saul Williams. That album was available online either for free or for $5 (for a higher-quality version). Under 20 percent of downloaders paid up, and Reznor complained that he couldn't even cover his costs for producing the album.
With Ghosts, Reznor had some obvious advantages. NiN is a better-known brand with a devoted following, and Reznor's strategy of using multiple price points made his music easily accessible to fans. Those who wished to pay nothing could download a free version of Ghosts I. For $5, a digital version of all four albums was available, and for only $10, fans could get all the music on CD along with an immediate digital download. $75 and $300 deluxe versions were also made available and include things like a Blu-ray disc, a DVD of the multitrack audio files from the project, videos, deluxe packaging, and more.
Can a ghost make you a millionaire?
For all the talk of Reznor "pulling a Radiohead," though, the actual strategy was different. There is no "choose your price" component, and there is no free download of the complete project from the NiN site. Instead, Reznor's strategy is more akin to the "free sample" model. It's also an attempt to move beyond the music biz's long-term fixation with a single product, the CD. Reznor is using five price points to segment his offerings, and the extra work this required appears to have paid off.
In covering the story, the New York Times noted that "one option Mr. Reznor is not offering fans is a way to obtain the entire collection free," but Ghosts I-IV is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike license that does allow noncommercial redistribution.
Even without a major marketing campaign, the album release generated so much interest that the NiN servers were knocked offline. Reznor apologized to fans, saying, "Sorry again about the hassle. Somebody kicked the plug out of our internets, but we're all set now."
Reznor gains something valuable from every transaction, even if downloaders elect not to pay; he harvests the e-mail addresses of fans interested in his music. These addresses are obviously marketing gold, but Reznor makes sure to treat his fans with respect, even when asking for their information. "We hate spam as much as you do, if not more so," he writes.
While it's routine now to hear media execs talk about how "people want to do the right thing" when it comes to paying artists, those comments are generally followed by a defense of lawsuits, DRM, and ISP filtering plans. The thinking goes that even in a world in which all locks can be picked, most people don't stop locking their doors. Reznor's experiment shows that the carrot approach can work well for artists, even with the stick.
- Broadcasters blast FCC localism proposals
- The Vista Capable mess: Intel pushes, Microsoft bends
- AOL's Open AIM 2.0 SDK license requires apps to include ads
- Think tank warns of an iCrime wave
- What piracy crisis? MPAA touts record box office for 2007
- Chinese official on SMS voting: "txtng votes ripe 4 abuse"
- Six botnets churning out 85 percent of all spam
- BlackBerry not taking iPhone innovations lying down
- Jobs spurns Flash for iPhone at shareholder's meeting
- "Maglev" refines haptic input technology
- OmniGraffle 5: Make diagrams people actually want to look at
- Rocketman: Axis of Evil lasers Xbox Live Arcade today
- Shuttle's $199 PC will ship with Foresight Linux
- Marc Ecko to bring serial killer Dexter to gamers
- Reminder: Live coverage of iPhone Software Roadmap
- PSN Store getting revamped in April
Reiterating the obvious—that Adobe's Flash is not fit for the iPhone—the question then becomes about what would work instead.
- Web Designer/Developer at Spectrum Communications Chicago, IL
- Development Lead at Microsoft Redmond, Washington
- Programmer Analyst - Tools at UC Santa Cruz - Staff Human Resources UC Santa Cruz, CA
- Applications Security Programmer Analyst at UC Santa Cruz - Staff Human Resources UC Santa Cruz, CA
- System/Network Admin at Clicktime.com, Inc. San Francisco, CA
Whitepapers from Intel:
- Quadcore and the Gigahertz Myth
- Server Rightsizing: Dual Socket Systems Cut Cost
- Wireless LAN as the Primary Network
- Policy-Based Virtual Infrastructure
- Web Services Technologies
- Optimizing WAN Performance for the Global Enterprise
- Second time around: a review of the Apple TV 2.0
- Pass or fail? RIAA’s college litigation campaign turns one
- Misperceptions meet state of the art in evolution research
- A land of indie games & clever controllers: GDC post-mortem
- Ars System Guide special: it's easy being green
- PC gaming is not dying, but is it becoming a second class platform?
- Given my current CPU, is an 8800 GT worth it?
- So finally a true street shooter?
- Im building a Gaming Rig. What OS to use?
- Ars System Guide, March 2008: Budget Box/Hot Rod/God Box
- Copyright coalition: Piracy more serious than burglary, fraud, bank robbery
- AT&T; willing to spy for NSA, MPAA, and RIAA
- MPAA: We are committed to fair use, interoperability, and DRM